Skip to Main Content
Benchwarmer's Tavern & Grill logo top - HomepageBenchwarmer's Tavern & Grill logo scroll - Homepage
  • (631)-509-4077
  • benchwarmers023@gmail.com
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Coupons
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
Benchwarmer's Tavern & Grill logo top - HomepageBenchwarmer's Tavern & Grill logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Coupons

Our Menu

  • Anytime Menu
  • Dinner Menu
  • Dessert Menu
  • Grill Room Dinners
  • Kids Menu
  • Catering Menu

*This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-bourne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions
*Surcharge applied to all Take-Out Orders*

Burgers

All burgers, sandwiches, and paninis are served with a side of fries, coleslaw & pickle.
Substitutions for sweet potato waffle fries, waffle fries, onion rings, tater tots or small salad is an additional price| Add Lettuce, Tomato or Onion

Marinated Burger*

Burger marinated in our house recipe and grilled to your liking

Cajun Burger*

Lightly Cajun dusted burger topped with crispy fried onion straws and buffalo wing sauce

Patty Melt*

Melted Swiss cheese & sautéed onions served on toasted marbled rye

Plain Burger*

8oz freshly ground beef burger

Cheeseburger*

Choose from American, cheddar, Swiss, mozzarella or bleu cheese crumbles

Turkey Burger*

8oz freshly ground turkey burger

Veggie Burger

Chopped vegetables made into a burger patty substitute

Burger Extras

Bacon, cheese, sautéed mushrooms, sautéed onions, or fried onion straws

Paninis, Sandwiches & Wraps

All burgers, sandwiches, and paninis are served with a side of fries, coleslaw & pickle.
Substitutions for sweet potato waffle fries, waffle fries, onion rings, tater tots or small salad is an additional price.

Reuben

Your choice of turkey, pastrami or corned beef topped with sauerkraut, 1000 island dressing & melted Swiss on marbled rye

Honey BBQ Chicken and Cheddar

Fried chicken topped with our signature honey BBQ sauce & melted cheddar cheese served on a toasted hero

French Dip

Thin sliced roast beef & melted mozzarella served on a garlic club roll with a side of au jus

Steak Hero*

Sliced steak topped with mozzarella cheese & crispy fried onions served on a toasted garlic hero

Grilled Chicken Panini

Grilled marinated chicken topped with fresh mozzarella cheese, spinach & roasted red peppers

Avocado Chicken Wrap

Grilled chicken, avocado, bacon, onion & tomatoes

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Fried chicken, lettuce, tomato, wing sauce & bleu cheese

Fajita Wrap

Your choice of plain or blackened chicken, jack cheese, avocado & sautéed peppers & onions

Caesar Wrap

Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce & Caesar dressing

Grilled Vegetable Panini

Grilled mushrooms, sautéed onions, spinach & Tomatoes topped with fresh mozzarella cheese & balsamic glaze

Pasta Entrees

All Pasta entrees come with your choice of penne or linguine | Add a Small House Salad or A Cup of Soup for additional cost | All pasta dishes are available gluten free

Penne Ala Vodka

Penne pasta tossed in a creamy pink vodka sauce | Add Chicken or Shrimp for additional cost

Pasta Primavera

Add Chicken or Shrimp for additional cost • Also available gluten free | Add Chicken or Shrimp for additional cost

*This menu item is cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish, or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illnesses, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
*Surcharge applied to all Take-Out Orders*

Appetizers

Baked Clams

Chopped clams mixed with fresh vegetables, lemon and garlic all topped with breadcrumbs and broiled in white wine butter

Wings

Jumbo Wings or Boneless Wings | Your choice of hot, medium, mild, honey BBQ, teriyaki or garlic parmesan served with a side of bleu cheese and celery

Chicken Fingers

Fried chicken tenders served with a side of honey mustard

Shrimp Cocktail

Served chilled with a side of cocktail sauce and a lemon

Calamari

Fresh flowered or buffalo style calamari fried and served with a side of marinara sauce and lemon

Mozzarella Sticks

Breaded mozzarella cheese served with a side of marinara sauce

Pretzel Sticks

Soft Bavarian pretzel twists baked with butter, topped with salt, and served with a cheddar cheese dipping sauce

Mini Tacos

Crunchy Hard-Shell tacos served with a side of salsa, sour cream, & melted cheddar cheese dipping sauce

Spinach and Artichoke Dip

Chopped spinach and artichoke hearts in a warm creamy garlic parmesan dip served with tortilla chips to dip

Potato Skins

Potato skins stuffed with melted cheeses & bacon served with a side of sour cream

Cheese Quesadilla

A melted cheddar cheese blend in a flour tortilla and served with a side of salsa and sour cream

Benchwarmer Sampler

Wings, mozzarella sticks, mini tacos and potato skins

Smothered Nachos

Tortilla chips topped with melted cheddar cheese, chili, olives, jalapeno, tomatoes & lettuce served with a side of salsa and sour cream

Marinated Steak Tidbits*

Tender cuts of sirloin marinated in our house marinade and served with a side of garlic bread and horseradish cream sauce to dip

Soups

Soup of the Day

Cup • Bowl

Crock of French Onion

Crock of Chili

Side of Tortilla Chips

Salads

Add on to any salad: sliced grilled chicken, shrimp, or sliced steak| Dressing choices: Bleu Cheese, Honey Mustard, Ranch, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Thousand Island, Italian, Red Wine Vinaigrette or Oil & Vinegar

Garden Salad

Iceberg lettuce topped with tomatoes, carrots, onions & croutons

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Romaine lettuce topped with crispy fried buffalo style chicken, tomatoes, red onions, and chopped bacon served with your choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing

Bruschetta Chicken Salad

Romaine lettuce topped with golden fried chicken, diced tomatoes, red onions, fresh mozzarella cheese, olive oil & drizzled with balsamic glaze

Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce and croutons sprinkled with parmesan cheese and drizzled with Caesar dressing

Cranberry Salad

Iceberg lettuce topped with dried cranberries, red onions, walnuts, tomatoes, and cucumbers served with your choice of dressing

Greek Salad

Iceberg lettuce topped with feta cheese, Kalamata olives, capers, roasted red peppers, red onions & tomatoes all served with red wine & vinaigrette dressing

Baskets

French Fries

Waffle Fries

Sweet Potato Fries

Tater Tots

Potato Chips

Onion Rings Basket

Chicken Finger Basket

Fish & Chips Basket

Menu

Cheesecake

Creamy New York Style Cheesecake Topped with whip Cream & Raspberry Drizzle

Chocolate Chip Brownie

Warmed Fudge Brownie served with your choice of chocolate or vanilla ice cream, chocolate syrup and whipped cream

Tartufo

Vanilla & Chocolate Ice Cream In a chocolate shell with a cherry & walnut Center

Skillet Cookie

Fresh baked cookie served with vanilla or chocolate ice cream, whipped cream, and chocolate syrup

Ice Cream

Enjoy Two scoops of vanilla or chocolate ice cream with whipped cream and your choice of syrup

4:00 PM to 10:00 PM

Menu

All dinners served with potatoes and mixed vegetables. | (Except for our Chicken Parmesan & Penne alla Vodka) | Add soup or salad French Onion

NY Shell Steak

Enjoy our shell steak plain, marinated, or cajun dusted cooked to your liking

Marinated Steak Tidbits

Marinated sirloin tidbits topped with mozzarella cheese and crispy onion straws

Bruschetta Chicken

Golden fried chicken breast topped with chopped tomatoes, onions, & fresh mozzarella cheese. Drizzles with a balsamic glaze

Chicken Parmesan

Golden fried chicken topped with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. Served with penne pasta and garlic bread

Penne alla Vodka

Penne pasta tossed in our creamy pink vodka sauce. Served with garlic bread

Add-ons

Add Chicken | Add Shrimp | Add Steak

*Prices subject to change

Menu

The kids’ menu is only served to children 12 and under. Each item is served with a drink and a scoop of ice cream.

Pasta

Penne or linguine served with your choice of marinara or butter

Grilled Cheese

Melted American served on your choice of white or marbled rye toast. Served with tater tots

Macaroni & Cheese

Chicken Fingers

3 chicken fingers served with a side of french fries

Hot Dog

1 grilled hot dog served with a side of french fries

Kids Burger

Choose from a plain or cheeseburger served with a side of french fries

Fish & Chips

2 fried cod filets served with a side of tater tots, tartar sauce and a lemon

*Prices and menu items subject to change without notice due to uncontrollable circumstances

Chicken

Chicken Francaise

Chicken Marsala

Chicken Parmesan

Chicken Cordon Bleu

Chicken Brushetta

Chicken Piccata

Chicken Cacciatore

Chicken and Broccoli

Beef, Pork & Turkey

Beef Teriyaki

Steak Tidbits

Sliced Roast Beef Au Jus

Meatballs

Swedish or Marinara

Sausage and Peppers

Pulled Pork

Stuffed Turkey Rollup

Stuffed Roast Beef Rollup

Fish

All Seafood items are priced per market value

Stuffed Shrimp with Crab Meat

Shrimp Scampi over Linguine

Shrimp Francaise

Shrimp Parmesan

Flounder Oreganata

Flounder Stuffed with Crab Meat

Pasta

Basked Ziti

Stuffed Shells

Penne Ala Vodka

Penne Ala Vodka with Chicken

Fettuccine Alfredo

Pasta Bolognese

Penne Carbonara

Bow Tie Pasta

Served with grilled chicken, sundried tomatoes, spinach and garlic and oil

Pasta in Garlic and Oil

Vegetables

Eggplant Parmesan

Eggplant Rollatini

Mixed Vegetables

String Beans

Heroes

Italian Hero

American Hero

Grilled Chicken Hero

Grilled chicken, mozzarella and mixed greens with a balsamic dressing

Sides and Salads

Mashed Potatoes

Rice

Macaroni and Cheese

Boneless Wings

Wings

Mozzarella Sticks

Caesar Salad

House Salad

Chicken Fingers

French Fries

  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs